Home / Questions / Border Collie
Yes, with a pattern to it. Border Collies bark at 4 out of 5 on our scale, and the barking is rarely random: arrivals, departures, other dogs, delivery drivers and the evening patrol of the garden cover most of it. The Border Collie is a Herding breed developed in United Kingdom (Anglo-Scottish border), and the voice is heritage, not habit. Expect barking at the door, at passersby and at anything that changes in the street. Expect much less of it from a Border Collie that has had its 90 to 120 minutes of exercise and something to think about, which is the management story the rest of this page tells.
A collie does not switch off. Owners who enjoy a dog that is a colleague rather than a companion animal find them unmatched; everyone else should admire them at a distance. A Border Collie is not a pet that fits around a life; it is a life that fits around a dog. The breed was shaped by shepherds along the border of England and Scotland, where dogs were selected purely for herding ability and the famous staring 'eye' used to control sheep. Famous sires like Old Hemp founded the modern breed in the 1890s.
Numbers first, because they explain the voice. The Border Collie carries a bark score of 4 of 5, flanked by energy at 5 of 5, shedding at 4 of 5 and grooming effort at 3 of 5. The breed needs 90 to 120 minutes of exercise a day, stands 18 to 22 inches and belongs to the Herding group, with roots in United Kingdom (Anglo-Scottish border). Its social ratings read Reserved with strangers for strangers and Usually good with dogs for other dogs, and both audiences feature in the barking story below.
Other dogs are a major chapter. A Border Collie that is rated Usually good with dogs still has opinions about dogs it can see and not greet, and the barking that results, at dogs on the other side of a fence, a window or a lead, is the breed's most common noise complaint. Arousal is the common thread, and this breed's very high energy means arousal is never far away. Barrier frustration adds its share: a dog that can see the street through glass or a fence but cannot reach it will comment on everything that passes, which is why so many high-score breeds are quieter in homes where the window show is managed rather than left running all day.
They are better with older children, having a herder's urge to control movement and a sensitive nature that dislikes household chaos. Other dogs are usually fine after socialization, while cats and small animals may be herded or chased. Training should be precise, consistent and endlessly interesting: this breed notices every inconsistency and files it.
For completeness, the record's remaining lines: the Border Collie comes from United Kingdom (Anglo-Scottish border), in the Herding group, and its color line reads: Black and white is classic; also red, merle, tricolor and sable. Its coat is recorded as Rough or smooth double coat, weather resistant. Apartment suitability is rated Not ideal, which is the line apartment readers should weigh beside the bark score, because a dog can be welcome in a flat for its size and unwelcome for its soundtrack, or the reverse. Its health watch list, Hip dysplasia, Collie eye anomaly and Epilepsy, belongs in the long view: a dog kept sound and lean is a calmer dog, and calm is the raw material quiet is made from.
Start with the first name on that shortlist, the Australian Shepherd, and the difference is already instructive: two breeds can share a build, a coat and a working past and still sit a full point apart on barking, because the score follows the breed's recorded temperament and heritage, not its silhouette. The Border Collie's 4 out of 5 should therefore be read as a measurement of this breed alone. The Border Collie's 4 out of 5 is its own: judge the noise by it, not by a lookalike's reputation, because two similar breeds can be very different neighbors.
If the barking is the neighborhood's problem as well as yours, escalate kindly and early: a force free behaviorist for a plan built on this breed's actual triggers, and a word with the neighbors before their complaint, because owners who explain the training plan get patience that owners who ignore the noise do not. What does not belong in the plan is punishment hardware or debarking talk; a breed whose voice is heritage, rated 4 out of 5, deserves management that works with the dog it is. The Border Collie can learn when to be quiet. It should never have to learn to be afraid of its own voice.
Adolescence brings maximum intensity, and structured sport or herding lessons turn the chaos into skill. Adults in their prime need the work program maintained or behavior unravels quickly.
A few record lines deserve a place in this decision. The Border Collie is a Herding breed from United Kingdom (Anglo-Scottish border), carrying a rough or smooth double coat, rated 3 of 5 for grooming effort and 4 of 5 for shedding. Barking 4 of 5, energy 5 of 5, trainability 5 out of 5. A small dog's 4 out of 5 and a giant dog's 4 out of 5 are different acoustic events, which is why the size lines belong on a page about noise: pitch, volume and the neighbor's tolerance all scale with the dog producing them.
Read two lines of the record together: barking at 4 out of 5 and apartment suitability rated Not ideal. For the Border Collie specifically, a Herding dog whose exercise needs run 90 to 120 minutes a day, that plays out in daily routines rather than in occasional big fixes. A low score with a good apartment rating is the easy yes. A high score means the honest answer depends on your walls, your neighbors and your willingness to run the management program on this page every day. What never works is hoping the dog did not get the memo about its own breed: a Border Collie will be exactly as vocal as its record says, in whatever building it lives in. In the wrong ones, no breed suffers more visibly.
Start with the cause, not the noise. In the Border Collie's case the setting matters as much as the rule: this is a breed with very high energy and a bark level of 4 out of 5, so its voice is heard against a fairly specific home backdrop. Meet the exercise need first, 90 to 120 minutes daily, then teach a settle cue in calm moments so it exists in loud ones, and reward the pauses after barking rather than shouting through them. Manage the stages the dog performs on, windows, fences, the front door routine. At 4 out of 5, this breed's trainability of 5 out of 5 makes the program very workable, but it is a program of weeks. Anyone selling you a silent Border Collie by Friday is selling you fear, not training. The Border Collie's intelligence is not a party trick; it is a full time occupation the dog is desperate to fill.
Puppies of every breed experiment with their voices, and a young Border Collie is no exception. With the Border Collie, whose typical weight runs 30 to 55 pounds and whose lifespan reaches 12 to 15 years, the honest answer also changes a little across the dog's life, from puppyhood to senior status at about 8 years. The adult pattern, the one the 4 out of 5 score describes, settles in across the first two years as the dog learns which events are routine. Households shape that settling more than they expect: puppies whose barking reliably summons company, play or opened doors keep the habit, while puppies whose calm behavior is what pays grow into the economy of voice their record promises. The breed loads the dice; the first year rolls them.
Last updated: November 11, 2026