Merrick Kitchen Comforts Chicken Casserole: our recipe review

Merrick · Kitchen Comforts Chicken Casserole · Wet food · Adult maintenance

On the facts printed on its own label, Merrick Kitchen Comforts Chicken Casserole scores 79 out of 100 on our rubric: a solid mid table label. The panel opens with Deboned Chicken, and the first ingredient signal earns 20 of its 20 points. At 8% crude protein it ranks 72 of the 82 Merrick recipes we scored for protein. Crude fat reads 3%.

Its adequacy claim rests on formulation: balanced on paper against the AAFCO nutrient profiles rather than fed to dogs in a trial. The brand carries 4 FDA posted recall events in our check, set out below with their dates; weigh their age as well as their count.

The panel runs to 41 ingredient lines. 3 of them are animal source lines and 8 are plant lines. The first added fat appears at line 35, so 34 lines sit ahead of it in the recipe by weight. Salt appears at line 12 of 41: ingredients listed after salt are present in small amounts, a standard reading aid for long panels. The vitamin and mineral pack begins around line 16; the 26 lines from there on are mostly supplements, preservatives and functional extras rather than staple foods.

The label facts

How the score breaks down

Ingredient notes: the first ten, one by one

Definitions below are written from AAFCO's ingredient definitions in our own words. They describe what an ingredient is, never what a brand claims about it.

• Deboned Chicken. Deboned Chicken is the named meat in fresh form. Panel order is set by weight before cooking, and fresh meat is mostly water, so its share of the finished food is smaller than its place at the top suggests.
• Chicken Broth. Chicken Broth is a cooking liquid from the named animal. It brings flavour and moisture, and in a wet food it is most of the weight in the can.
• Dried Egg Product. Dried Egg Product has already had its water taken out before it is weighed in, so a kilo of it stands for several kilos of the fresh meat. It is one of the most protein dense forms an ingredient can take.
• Brown Rice. Brown Rice is a milled grain used for energy and to bind the kibble. Whole grain forms keep the bran and bring gentle fibre with them.
• Carrots. Carrots is a fruit or vegetable inclusion. At panel positions like this the amounts are small; treat them as garnish with benefits, not a nutrient pillar.
• Green Beans. Green Beans is a legume bringing starch, fibre and plant protein. Several legume lines together can rival the meat share of a recipe.
• Sweet Potatoes. Sweet Potatoes is a starchy root used to bind kibble and add energy, with useful fibre and beta carotene.
• Natural Flavor. Natural Flavor is a flavouring: a spray or powder added so the food tastes stronger to the dog. It is not a protein source and our rubric does not count it as one.
• Agar-Agar. Agar-Agar sits on the panel as a functional ingredient: a binder, supplement or processing aid rather than a nutrient base.
• Guar Gum. Guar Gum sits on the panel as a functional ingredient: a binder, supplement or processing aid rather than a nutrient base.

The brand's recall record

2010: Merrick treats were recalled across July and August 2010 in one expanding FDA posted chain: Beef Filet Squares first, then Texas Hold'ems, then all lots of both, over possible Salmonella contamination. The FDA's first word on these treats was a health alert on January 14, 2010, the first notice of this same event, counted once.

2011: Merrick Jr. Texas Taffy pet treats were recalled in January 2011 over possible Salmonella contamination.

2011: Merrick Doggie Wishbone pet treats were recalled in August 2011 over possible Salmonella contamination.

2018: FDA posted a recall of limited Merrick and Castor and Pollux beef dog treats over potentially elevated levels of naturally occurring beef thyroid hormone. The event covered treats, not foods.

All four events covered treats rather than complete foods, and three of them date from 2010 and 2011. We count them, labelled as treats, because they speak to the maker's quality systems across its history.

See the full dog food recall tracker for recent events across all brands.

Other Merrick recipes we scored

Those are the twelve highest scoring of the 81 other Merrick recipes we scored. The full comparison, flagship review included, is on the Merrick brand review.

Feeding it

Switch foods gradually over about a week, mixing more of the new food into the old each day. Portion by calories, not by the look of the bowl: our feeding calculator works out a daily amount from your dog's weight, and this recipe's calorie line above is the number it needs.

What that means at the bowl, for a typical neutered adult (resting energy 70 times body weight to the power 0.75, times 1.6; treats come out of the same budget):

Puppies, pregnant dogs and very active dogs need more; older and weight watching dogs need less. The calculator linked above adjusts for those cases.